After being granted access to the royal ball by making a deal with Rumplestiltskin, Cinderella meets Prince Thomas and they fall in love, before eventually getting married. Afterwards, Cinderella finds out that she's pregnant and Rumplestiltskin confronts her, saying that the price for getting her to the ball is going to be her newborn baby. Frightened of her child's fate, Cinderella tells Thomas of Rumplestiltskin's price, and they work with Snow White and Prince David, along with the dwarves and they construct a prison that will hold Rumplestiltskin, using magical squid ink to imprison him.
In Storybrooke, after the first Dark Curse, Cinderella has been pregnant for 28 years. When the daughter of Snow and David, Emma Swan, arrives in Storybrooke and causes time to start moving again, she eventually goes into labor. Emma finds out that Rumplestiltskin, known as Mr. Gold in Storybrooke, has made a deal to give away her baby to another family and is willing to pay Cinderella. Emma stops Gold from pursuing Cinderella and her baby, by offering a deal of her own, telling him that she will owe him a favour if he leaves Cinderella's baby alone. Gold eventually agrees.
- The King (paternal grandfather)
- Thomas Herman (father)
- Cinderella (mother)
- Lady Tremaine (maternal step grandmother)
- Clorinda Tremaine (maternal step aunt)
- Tisbe Tremaine (maternal step aunt)